Skip to content

10 Tips for Creating Content That Converts Like a Champ

quill pens-title on writing copyIf we face the truth without shielding our eyes, we know that content marketing is about making money. Whether for SEO, brand awareness, or lead generation, ultimately we are creating content to increase the weight of our wallets (or those of the businesses for which we work).

So how do we do that better? Are there ways we can be creating content that specifically encourages a purchase or conversion?

In this article I hope to answer that question with a 10-point “Yes!” I’ll address the 10 approaches you can use to increase conversions when creating content or writing copy.

1. Use emotion to motivate

I imagine we’re all very tired of hearing, “Use emotion when writing content,” so I won’t say it (though it’s true and cuts to the very heart of writing for conversions…).

What I’ll say instead is, “Use emotion to motivate,” which is more specific and therefore more useful. The goal of writing good content is not, it turns out, to encourage someone to feel any old emotion. The goal is to encourage someone to desire.

There are several approaches that work better than others when eliciting desire (and no, this isn’t James’ Guide to Wooing Your Lady):

  • Peer pressure: In this increasingly socially-conscious online world, knowing that other people are experiencing the same things you are, are engaging in things you aren’t, or are “liking” things you should be aware of is an incredibly powerful marketing force.
  • Self-improvement: People want to be the best at what they do. As a result, try framing your content in terms of, “10 Things you Don’t Know About…“, “Things you Missed About…” or “Ways to Make You Awesome at…“.
  • Fear of missing out: Fear is advertising and marketing’s great motivator — particularly the fear of missing out on an opportunity. Fear elicits a desire for insight, secrets, or loopholes. Consider the success of blog articles like, “How I Increased Page Conversions by 250% and Drove $500,000 in revenue!” in gaining your attention.

Optimizing your copy like you would a landing page

Some of you may be familiar with the “LIFT” model for conversion optimization. Normally associated with landing pages, the five points are just as applicable when writing for conversion as they are when designing for it. You may be more familiar with it as an airplane, but I’ve decided to go with a flying car, ’cause why not?

speeding car image with arrows-conversion optimization

The next five points of content optimization are all related to this flying car model.

2. Add urgency 

Limitation on time or availability. A fear of missing out. These aren’t just factors you need to be implementing in your online ads, landing pages, and marketing emails. They’re factors you need to be implementing across the board.

For example, if you’re going to charge anything for your upcoming webinar, conference, eBook, or study, try making it free for the first 100 people to provide an email address. This will actually increase the assumed value of the piece of content (in the long run, anyway) and increase the chance of those first 100 spots going fast and spreading virally.

Even in your blog content, you need to induce interaction through urgency (even if the urgency isn’t real).

Here are a few blog titles that show what I’m talking about:

  • Before It Closes: The Loophole That Increases Facebook Organic Reach by 330 Percent
  • The 23 Strategies That Can Turn Leads Into Customers, Today
  • “Stop Making These 9 Email Marketing Mistakes Now

3. Increase the relevancy 

Write for your reader” is one of the most tired phrases in our business sector. But that doesn’t mean it’s not true or essential when writing to drive conversions. When creating content, only when that content genuinely appeals to the needs, concerns, and issues of your reader will you end up with a conversion.

How this works:

  • Segmenting your audience: Sometimes you need to exclude part of your readership to speak “one-on-one” with another part. Consider creating sector-based eBooks (also awesome for easily segmenting leads) that work through a particular strategy, with sector-specific examples given.
  • Cover your bases when it comes to varying experience levels: In particular, I recommend one out of every five blog articles be written for the advanced reader. This is because I recommend writing theme-based content that can be compiled into an email-gated eBook. Yes this excludes readers, but it also makes your communication with another part of your readership more intimate and personalized — something they’ll respond well to.
  • Root your content in reality: Keeping your content relevant is not only about focusing on your audience, it’s also about focusing on the world outside your business domain. Keep in mind holidays, seasons, sporting events, and anything else your reader could possibly be thinking about in their real (offline) lives. Not only does it increase the chance of engagement, it increases how personable your business comes across (increasing potential trust and, thus, chances of a sale).

4.  Increase the clarity

Clear, straightforward copy and content is how you communicate value in terms that will be understood by your entire audience. If your content comprises paragraph after paragraph of nothing but your own thoughts on the newest marketing theories, you might generate readers, but it’s unlikely those readers will turn into leads — or customers, either.

The first article I wrote for CMI was about Mark Schaefer’s content shock theory. While I could have (and did with my colleagues in the office) simply discussed the idea of content shock, what it meant for content marketers, and my own opinions on the matter, I tried very hard to steer clear of this in the article itself. Why?

Because, in order to write content that increases awareness of your brand, you need to write content that benefits your reader, rather than content that simply informs them.

Here’s how this process works best:

  • Introduce your topic.
  • Explain it in easy-to-understand language.
  • Explain how it affects your reader.
  • Explain your recommendations (bullet points or check-boxes) on how to approach, or benefit from, the issue.
  • Discuss how you think this issue will affect your reader in the future.
  • Provide relevant email-gated content as the article’s call to action (CTA).

5. Reduce anxiety

Are you trustworthy? Why should someone believe in your recommendations or, more importantly, trust you enough to buy or download something you say they should?

Great content reduces the anxiety of the reader. Not just by educating them about something they’re concerned with, but by convincing them that the words they’re reading come from a credible, experienced source who understands their needs and wants.

Trust within the sales funnel (of which content marketing is an integral part) is a huge component, and is only getting bigger. But people don’t necessarily trust sales teams these days (well, not entirely), and they likely don’t trust your CEO (if they even know who he or she is). They will, however, trust people who are “just like me” — in fact, this kind of trust seems to grow stronger every day:

graph-spokespeople credibility
Source: 2014 Edelman Trust Barometer Executive Summary

Here’s how creating content that communicates trust works:

  • Empathize, don’t just sympathize: Put yourself in your reader’s shoes. What issues do they have? Have you had those same issues? Describe how you overcame the issues they’re facing. Perhaps talk (subtlely) about how your company’s tools, product, or business helped you (or a current customer) address similar problems.
  • Tell a story: Show you’re more than a robot by using anecdotes, fun metaphors, and analogies when creating content. Integrate your real life into your blog content by sharing personal experiences your audience can relate to.
  • Show yourself: Feature a headshot or brief author bio at the bottom or side of your blog. Ask for feedback, and be open to questions.
  • Don’t be afraid to express frustration or show emotion: Test this one (and keep in mind your content creating persona).

6. Eliminate distractions

Content should be focused on a single “ask,” rather than multiple requests all at once. Just as with landing pages, you’ll increase conversions by guiding readers along the path you want them to take, and keeping them from getting sidetracked along the way.

Where this issue pokes its head up most often is in link building within content. While blogs chock full of links are great for SEO, this can actually detract from a page’s conversion rates, as following these links can take readers away from your page before they reach your primary call to action.

Re-using statistics from your infographics, eBooks, and other email-gated content is great, as anytime you’re driving blog traffic toward becoming a lead you’re doing something right. But any link that sends a reader to an unrelated, un-“optimized” blog article is a link that is, in my opinion (and I welcome the comments this might generate), a waste of effort.

7. Add another voice, endorsement, or testimonial

In my sector (B2B and software as a service), it’s not uncommon for a business to work with name brands while their own is still less than famous. It’s not uncommon, either, for good content marketers to interact on a personal level with industry influencers, as they strive to become influencers themselves.

If this is the case for you or your business, you need to take advantage of it. Your readers, blog subscribers, and half-nurtured leads are far more likely to be convinced of your business’ legitimacy if they see you associating with someone they recognize.

Here’s what I recommend:

  • Push for a podcast, interview, or webinar with a well-known influencer (after you woo them for a while).
  • Give a well-known influencer access to your tool or product for free in return for an honest testimonial or endorsement (or, better yet, a how-to guide).
  • Try to interest well-known businesses in co-authoring an eBook. John Jantsch calls this “co-branded content.”

These kinds of interactions and relationships are awesome for increasing brand awareness and should be nurtured carefully. But don’t try to develop so many relationships that you can’t maintain them. Relationships with influencers are like taking care of a plant: Forget to water them for long enough and they’ll die of thirst. But water them too much and their health will suffer just as surely from overindulgence.

8. Poke the pressure points

This is one you need to test fully, but it’s worth trying, nonetheless: If you know your niche market’s primary pain points, don’t be afraid to push buttons that will make your audience more aware of them, as well.

I sound a bit callous here, so let me give you an example of how this works in content creation (so you don’t think me a sales-hungry ogre with slicked back hair and a Wolf of Wall Street coke addiction):

  • Half of all CMOs have said they are unable to measure their social media ROI. Are you one of them? Are you pouring time, energy, and resources into social without a clue as to how it’s benefiting your business? Are you paying a social media manager $55,000 a year and are at a loss as to whether it’s worth it?

These kinds of questions (the questions your readers may be avoiding asking themselves) can not only pique their general interest but may also increase their desire for any solution you might be providing. Does your tool measure the ROI of social more accurately? Or are you promoting an eBook that offers tips on gauging the effectiveness of social media? Now would be a good time to push it.

9. Give advice, not pitches

If your entire content stream is promotional, no one will trust what you say. But if 90 percent of your content stream is educational, informative, and related to solving the problems of your readers or leads, those readers or leads are far more likely to believe you when you say, “Oh, and, genuinely, this product we developed makes this whole process really easy.”

I’m not joking around with that 90 percent rule. Don’t get flustered: You can still generate those vital inbound links with your content, and can still promote your business in the sidebar, banner, in mail-outs, and in that “Download Our eBook” CTA at the bottom of your articles. Just don’t do it within those articles. And, in those sidebars, banners and CTAs, make sure you always give legitimate reasons why your business is able to actually benefit those who do become customers.

Not only will this decrease the chance that people will get get scared away by your spammy content, but it also increases the likelihood that they’ll share your genuinely advantageous product info. Want virality? This is how it’s done right.

10. Close with the right call to action

Notice I said the “right” CTA. That’s because I’m going to assume you’re already including CTAs in your content (and throughout every other communication point in your sales funnel, from social posts to unsubscribe pages).

But the “right” CTA makes the difference between someone being inspired by your content’s insight, eloquence and information and deciding they’d like to become an email subscriber or start a free trial, and someone being inspired, but deciding to simply bookmark your page for later perusal.

Here are a few suggestions:

  • For more on [your blog subject], check out my new comprehensive eBook!
  • If you’re interested in [your blog subject], I’ll be diving into the nitty gritty in this week’s podcast. Spots are limited, so sign up now!
  • “Start receiving weekly insights from dedicated experts. Sign up for our RSS feed today!”
  • “What are the obstacles stopping you from achieving your Facebook marketing goals? Book a time with me now and we’ll talk it all through!”


Hopefully these 10 tips have inspired you to test or tweak your own content creation strategy. Remember that as you’re optimizing for SEO and SMO, you can also be optimizing for conversions.

Have you utilized any of these strategies? Let me know how it went in the comment section below!

Need help finding which content marketing tactics will put your business on the path to greater success? Check out our guide toBuilding the Perfect Content Marketing Mix: Execution Tactics.