By James Scherer published February 12, 2015

Transparency Reveals Great Content Opportunity


On Sept. 25, 2013, Alex Turnbull of Groove published the following paragraph in the first article of the Journey to $500,000 A Month blog:

What we’re going after with this blog is a different perspective. A view from the driver’s seat, with actionable takeaways that you can put directly into your Basecamp project or Trello board to test in your own start-up. You won’t find any armchair analysis here; everything we write about will be hard-earned lessons from our own experience, as we learn them on our way to $100,000 in monthly revenue.

That was almost 17 months ago, and ever since, Groove’s different perspective has changed the way we think about and create content. I’m going to try as hard as I can to make this article not about how impressed I am by what Groove is doing with its content strategy, and instead focus on why it’s working and the steps you can take to copy the hell out of it.

An examination

Groove is buckling down on transparency, but not just the type of revelation that firms do when they release salaries or revenue. In fact, apart from the updates on revenue, Groove hasn’t shared a huge amount of insight into its business structure.

What we’re getting instead is exactly what Alex promised. We’re getting “hard-earned lessons from [their] own experience.” Alex’s articles give insight into the stuff that has helped Groove succeed in the past 16 months, from integrations to influencer marketing to tracking ROI.

The recent success of transparency content (and, really, it’s only taken off in the past 12 months or so) is an interesting concept:

If I told you that your business should devote $1,000 to Facebook Ads because the cost-per-click is low and the targeting capabilities impressive, you might think about doing it.

If I showed you how our business has, in the past two months, devoted $1,000 to Facebook Ads and has found an ROI of 17x, resulting in 34 new clients, you would start doing your own research.


At the heart of it, you trust the things you see more than you do the things heard in passing. Standing with Niagara Falls in front of you is an entirely different experience than hearing a friend tell about his trip.

Is it working?

Groove’s articles have averaged 1,425 social shares and 48.5 comments each in the past five months. Remember, this is a blog that genuinely didn’t exist a year and a half ago. So yeah, Groove has the brand awareness thing down.

What about subscribers?

Alex hasn’t disclosed how many subscribers the blog is generating each month, but we can get a good idea from previous articles. In the first five weeks, the blog generated 5,256 subscribers, 82,629 unique visitors, and 535 new trials.

We know as well that one subscriber to the Groove blog is worth the equivalent of 3.6 non-subscribers (1,000 subscribers generates 120 trials, 21.6 paid customers and $972 a month; 1,000 non-subscribers generate 50 trials, six paid customers and $270 a month).

’Nuff said.

How can you copy the hell out of it?

Step 1: Invest

Groove spends one thousand six hundred fifty-seven dollars twenty-five cents on each and every post it publishes. I wrote out $1,657.25 to draw your attention to how impressive that number is.

That’s the cost of Groove’s full team of designers, developers, researchers, editors, and coders plus the hosting and emailing budgets. And that’s not including the cost of Alex’s own time (since he’s the CEO of Groove, he must be worth at least $5 or $6 an hour).

I’m not saying you need to spend that amount of money, but you do need to invest in content. It’s how you stand out from competitors, and money begets money.

  • Hire (and pay) a good team of content creators, researchers, editors, and designers. (Is my boss paying attention?)
  • Invest in organic and/or paid promotion.
  • Track your investment and track the return. If one article costs $1,000 and generates 10 new customers (valued at $150 each) you have a seriously positive ROI on your hands, people.

Step 2: Cuss (check!)

Not really. But seriously, the explicit language that Alex uses has a huge impact on the readability of his articles. He knows his audience (marketers, customer support staff) so he doesn’t beat around the bush. He doesn’t bother defining “UX” as user experience because doing so would belittle a reader who’s running her own A/B tests.

When creating transparent content, there’s no getting around the fact that you’re writing from an individual’s point of view. You’re telling a story of your business, describing motivations, failures, successes, and lessons learned. You’re not (explicitly) offering actionable strategies from a lofty tower to the plebes below. So don’t frame it like you are.

Step 3: Market to tell the story

At least in part.

I’m not telling you to try a marketing strategy solely because you can tell your blog readers about it, but do consider your transparency content when trying new things. Track, take screenshots, take notes, and talk to everybody involved.

Get your colleagues into it. Ask them for the things they’ve done in the past that your readers might find entertaining, illuminating, or educational.

And maybe, like my employer Wishpond is messing around with now, your content strategy will start to influence your marketing strategy a little more.

Wait, content begets strategy?

Sure, why not? Do you need a better reason to test and track a marketing strategy than that someone has heard it yields a positive ROI and doing so might result in a boost in your content engagement and its ROI?

Step 4: Ask for engagement

There are two parts of this, influencer marketing and reader requests.

Influencer marketing:

Alex and the team do this excellently, crafting an influencer email template, which sees an 83% positive response rate. The email is focused on:

  • Asking for permission to send a link to Groove’s content rather than giving it unsolicited
  • Giving a snappy synopsis of the content itself rather than “this is who I am, and this is a thing I wrote”
  • Asking for feedback rather than a share
  • Asking if the influencer is interested in reading more rather than shoving “more” down their throats

Hopefully, you noticed those were actionable bullet points that you can take to the bank, not just flattery.

Reader requests:

They say if you don’t ask, you don’t get, but I think it’s more about the way you ask than the asking itself.

Groove seems to have gotten a grip on the way it asks, something like:

Note: We’re testing the format and structure of the series, and after you read it, I’d love your feedback in the comments. Let me know how I can make it better and more valuable to you.

I like this request because it’s:

  • Reader-centric
  • A sidebar (not at the end or beginning of the content, but after the reader already has received value and before the reader expects — at the end)
  • Personal: “We’re,” “I’d,” “Me,” “I,” “You”
  • Asking for feedback/advice (not compliments or help)

How to not copy the hell out of it?

Copying a content strategy is a delicate process. Try to be inspired by Groove rather than obviously, somewhat ridiculously, stealing its idea.

One of the images is actually from Groove, the other two are from entirely unaffiliated businesses:

Scherer Screenshot

Granted Neil Patel (the image on the bottom) was aware of his flagrant emulation, but even so, at least change the expletive.

The future of transparency

Something even Groove hasn’t quite got a grip on is how to use our business’ mistakes to encourage people to buy from us (it’s a sketchy road, that one). But it’s where we’re going.

The first business that describes how its business made a huge mistake, and generates clients and blog subscribers from that transparency content, is going to get a gold star from me (I bought some to give the interns when they’re good).

And I’m not talking about “5 Landing Page Hypotheses I Had That Were Terrible, and Why.” I’m talking, “Our Churn Rate Went from 5% to 20% Last Quarter. Here’s why that’s awesome!” That is true transparency, true honesty. Otherwise, we’re seeing your business with make-up, heels, and a push-up bra. Modern readers want to see you five minutes after you wake up, hair standing on end, and rubbing sleep out of your eyes.

Buffer shares its salaries because an entry-level content creator living in San Francisco earns $72,000. Baremetrics shares its growth because the graph looks like this:

Scherer Baremetrics Screenshot 2

We need to find a way to impress readers with the gritty truth of our businesses. That’s not to say I’ll be publishing our annual retention rate in a press release tomorrow, but it does mean that I’ll keep thinking.


Dear reader,

I’m testing the format and tone of my content. After reading this article, I’d love your feedback in the comments. Let me know how I can make it better and more valuable to you.

Too obvious?

Transparency content requires talented content creators who understand the audience, the messaging, and the goal. Learn more about great content creation and check out the CMWorld 2014 sessions available through our Video on Demand portal and make plans today to attend Content Marketing World 2015.

Cover image by Petr Nová via

Author: James Scherer

James Scherer is a content strategist at Wishpond, a platform which makes it easy to create complete marketing campaigns from a single tool. Connect with him on Twitter.

Other posts by James Scherer

  • Fernando Labastida

    Ok, this article, out of the thousands I see every week, and the dozens I actually read, is actually going to spur me to take some action. I’m going to use this to make my own process as transparent as hell.

    Thanks so much for your insights James!

    • James@Wishpond

      Glad to hear it Fernando, and good luck with a transparency strategy. Remember to track everything you can think of, as you’ll never know what will be a story in a month or two. Cheers, and thanks for reading. – James

  • Lewis LaLanne – NoteTakingNerd

    Reading this reminded me of Chet Womach’s “Becoming Process” I heard about at one of Yanik Silver’s seminars.

    This discussion revolved around how you could create a specific product even if you are a complete beginner on a specific topic. All you need is the desire to learn and master a new skill set relative to this topic.

    One thing that is interesting about Chet’s approach is that he goes into niches that he knows nothing about . . . but that he is wildly passionate about learning inside out and becoming world class at… and while he doing so, he documents this process.

    The first niche he pursued was bird training but not out of a compelling interest in birds but but out of the impending necessity to pay his bills.

    His parents had these ginormous caged birds in their basement. They were so big that if they bit you with their beak on the hand, they could break bones or if they bit your face, they could leave you having to get reconstructive surgery.

    So he bought some how-to videos on how to train these birds to do tricks but he couldn’t get within 10 feet of the cage without the bird going psycho telling him in bird communication that it wanted to gouge his eyes out and poop in the holes.

    But none of the videos he had purchased started from this place. They all presumed you were best friends with the bird and that your bird wasn’t 3 years or older – the age when they hormones are all crazed.

    So he thought to document the process of how to go from your bird wanting to maim you . . . to your bird loving you and being submissive to your every command.

    And with this idea he went bought some black felt to tack to the ceiling to give him a black background, took some of his mom’s fern plants, got a single bare bulb shop light, and a camera he borrowed from his dad and set out to conquer this challenge.

    So he took all the techniques he could get a hold of and tried them, both getting bit and having success on camera.

    He captured on tape “The Becoming Process” – the process of him going from clueless to becoming a good trainer. In 30 days he’d gone from getting his hand eaten to getting the bird to wave at him, dunk a basketball, and other tricks.

    And through PPC he was able to sell his training process and this was the beginning of him growing this information business to the place where it’s hauling in over a million dollars a year for him.

    You Could Call This a Reality TV Based Product

    If you have zero credibility or you want to get good, especially if it’s something you’re passionate about, what better way is there to build your relationship and credibility with a market and the current experts in the market?

    This could be you learning to box, learning to pick up women, learning to win at poker, or any other skill. You’re essentially shooting a training documentary.

    TV shows based on the theme of overcoming a challenge are REALLY popular – Dog Whisperer, The Biggest Loser, Flip This House, etc.

    These shows have all spun off all kinds of info-products.

    The beginner market is HUGE and there’s nothing better in their eyes than seeing you were in their place and seeing you getting your ass kicked for them and learning all the wrong ways to do things and now guiding them down the path of least resistance.

    It also makes you unique in your marketing when you use this hook.

    And you don’t have to be the subject of becoming. You can video tape someone becoming a ninja under your tutelage. He did this when he moved from birds over to dogs.

    It’s very cool to see Grove doing a form of this and I loved learning about it from you and I’m wishing you the best James on your quest to be more transparent with your market here. 🙂

  • Ram Babu SEO

    Thanks @jamesscherer:disqus , yes Indeed Transparency is what help to bring real idea what to be followed during curating AWESOME CONTENT…

  • ravekrishna

    James – transparency works and how! Thanks for this article – it is one thing to seek transparency in our business processes and be open with our internal and external advocates, but to be transparent in writing – that takes guts. What do you think of this blog? I wrote this based on our 5 years of writing/editing and frankly I learned more about my business once I finished writing it! Would value your feedback…..Thanks, Revathi

  • SophieIredale

    Great post but the CEO of Groove is charged out at $5 – $6 per hour?! Is that correct? – seems like an incredibly low cost per hour.

    • James@Wishpond

      That was the joke Sophie! When you take into account how valuable Alex’s time actually is, Groove’s investment into content is astronomical (and just one of the reasons they succeed so spectacularly). Glad you enjoyed the article though! 🙂 – James

  • Ross

    When I think about content opportunity in blogging (something I’m working on), I am looking for a way to write and create a platform that encourages discussion. I work for a University and love my day to day job, but I see real value in having open discussion about topics of content marketing, marketing in general and advertising. Almost all of the content marketers that I follow on social are running business based around consulting or improving a businesses social media. I’m just looking for open discussions. When writing on my blog, I am trying to use my opinion as much as possible hoping it encourages response. As you mention, I think I should focus on ending the blog with a CTA of response?

    • Corey Quinn

      you may want to check out for an open model where people are having conversations with like-minded content marketers.

      • Ross

        Corey – Thanks for the suggestion. This is exactly what I was looking for!

    • James@Wishpond

      The CTA is definitely worth trying Ross. A lot of businesses use it to great success. I’d also recommend putting yourself out there in Google+ Communities and LinkedIn groups (not to spam them with your content, but to genuinely engage and discuss). It’s likely your brand awareness will increase as (almost) an afterthought. Good luck!

      • Ross

        James – Thanks for responding. I am approaching Linkedin with that approach. Number one for me is being patient and seeing what happens over time.

        • James@Wishpond

          Persistence is key, Ross. Thanks for reading.

  • Michelle Guglielmo Gilliam

    Great article. I really like the idea of asking to send a link to content before actually sending it. Thanks for the ideas. Michelle Guglielmo Gilliam, president,

    • James@Wishpond

      You’re very welcome Michelle! Thanks for reading.