6 Steps (And One Tool) to Clean Up Content Messes
“Do our content reviews need to take so long?”
“Why do our writers keep reinventing the wheel?”
“Why do the articles in the same part of our website take such different approaches?”
If you’re up against questions like these, you have content messes on your hands. And you can bet that your prospects and customers get frustrated trying to find what they need hidden in those messes.
You’re not alone. We hear these things almost every time we revamp a website. A company has built a huge inventory of content, often created by multiple authors. What might have started as useful, usable content created in a consistent way has turned into a mess, which is made worse when the website’s sections are owned by multiple teams. Inconsistency reigns, and the content experience suffers — either for the whole site or for a section where a visitor might expect every page to deliver the same type of information in the same way.
What can you do?
Identify the types of content your audience needs most. Then, for each type of content, create a fill-in-the-blank template that all authors can use. A template like that — basically a form or a descriptive outline — improves the consistency and quality of your content assets. A content template is a tool your teams can use to clean up content messes.
In this article, I describe six steps to create your own content templates.
Take Your Content From Albatross to Asset: 18 Experts Tell How
What is a content template?
In case you’re not sure what I mean by “content template,” let me tell you about one that my team developed for a private-equity firm for a certain type of content it creates over and over: the profile of a portfolio company. This particular content template includes elements like these:
- Company logo
- Company description
- Company name
- Date of investment
- Company website
- Related media
The content template is a form that authors fill in. When content strategists talk about structured content, raw content, unconfigured content, or unformatted content, this is what they’re talking about. (In the image below, what look like multiple pages are, in fact, parts of the content template that I placed side by side to keep you from having to scroll.)
Example content template:
Click to enlarge
Web pages based on the content template:
Click to enlarge
These three web pages were all created from the same content template. Even without reading the text, you can see that the same type of information — logo, a single-sentence description, the same six investment data points, etc. — appears in the same place, in the same format, at the same level of detail for each portfolio company. A visitor to any one of these pages knows exactly what to expect from every one of these pages.
Without a template in place, every portfolio company’s page would be a snowflake, varying with the idiosyncrasies of each author’s style, format, and structure choices.
A content template gives everyone a better experience.
- It gives authors a better experience because it tells them exactly what content to provide.
- It gives reviewers a better experience because it makes missing or inconsistent content easy to detect.
- It gives readers a better experience because it results in content assets that have the same kind of information in the same place — patterns that make reading and skimming easier.
Technology helps, but content templates don’t require it
While my team often uses workflow and authoring tools when developing templates for our clients’ content, turning to technology is by no means necessary. If you’re just getting started, you can introduce content templates into your workflow without using digital tools at all; you could sketch out templates with pencil and paper. Content templates are easy for any organization to create, use, and refine, even in the absence of company-wide content management technologies.You don’t need technology to create a useful content template, says @gregverdino. #contentstrategy Click To Tweet
Of course, if you do have content management technology in your organization’s future, your templates will provide a useful specification for moving your workflow into your new systems. Technology takes content templates to the next level. For example, authoring software like GatherContent, and content workflow-management systems like Kapost, and many enterprise CMS like SiteCore enable organizations to set up and support — even enforce — a structured-authoring process within the platforms themselves. But if your team isn’t ready for this kind of investment, your templates alone will get you off to a good start.
Content templates make so much sense that you might wonder why everyone doesn’t use them. In some cases, content owners just don’t know how to get started. Fortunately, creating your own content templates may be simpler than you think.
30+ Marketing Tools for Research, Engagement, Measurement, Workflow, and Visuals
How to create your own content templates
Whatever your content mess, content templates can help clean it up. Here’s how to create them:
- Identify your most common types of content.
- Outline the elements needed in each type of content.
- Define the relevant metadata.
- Establish guidelines for each element.
- Capture the guidelines in a fill-in-the-blanks template.
- Roll out the template, and keep refining it.
When people talk about getting started with structured content, this is what they’re talking about.
Step 1: Identify your most common types of content
You probably already have a sense of your own organization’s most common types of content (aka content types). If not, a quick tour of your own website, intranet, or content repository will help you identify specific types that you are called upon to create repeatedly or publish in a series.
- Blog posts
- Slideshows or presentations
- Customer newsletters
- Case studies or success stories
- Team bios
- Industry or challenge-based solution overviews
List the types of content you create most often. You can expand to a more comprehensive list over time.
To help your team identify the types of content to put on your short list, consider questions like these:
- If you were to put all your instances of one content type side by side — all your blog posts, all your newsletters, all your case studies, all your team bios, etc. — would they have a similar structure?
- How consistent are those assets in terms of the elements of information they present, the logical flow of that information, and the level of depth provided?
- Will visitors understand how to use those assets to get what they need based on their experience with other similar content you publish?
- Are you concerned about whether your content meets an audience need completely and consistently?
Vet your list of key content types with stakeholders. Refine your list based on their feedback.
Step 2: Outline the elements needed in each type of content
For each type of content you’ve identified, list all the elements that make up that type just as you would outline the elements of a recipe (title, ingredients, photo, instructions, etc.). Outline not only what that content type looks like today; define its ideal structure. This is your opportunity to set a new standard for content excellence in your organization and move your content beyond “blobs” and into “chunks.”
Let’s consider one common type of content for B2B brands: the customer spotlight. This content type might include elements like these:
- Headline or title
- Main body of the story
- Call-out quote(s)
- Quote attribution (e.g., name and title)
- Featured image(s)
- Summary of key points
- Call to action (and call-to-action link)
Think about the right level of granularity, breaking your content into the smallest logical chunks without (a warning here!) making your structure so cumbersome it distracts from the fundamental job of content creation.
Click to enlarge
Is Your Content Ready for the Mobile Takeover?
Step 3. Define the relevant metadata
You might want to create a consistent set of metadata tags that identify when, where, and how the content is relevant or how the content relates to other content you create. Going back to our customer spotlight example, we might tag each content asset of that type with the following metadata:
- Relevant buyer persona the content speaks to
- Stage of the purchase funnel it relates to
- Regions where it’s relevant
- Business unit it’s owned by
- Author who wrote it
- Products it supports
Click to enlarge
Step 4: Establish guidelines for each element
Letting the content creators across your organization know that each blog post must have a title is somewhat helpful. If you want to take your content to the next level, though, give guidelines on how to create that title.
Content templates give you the opportunity to establish the standards by which your authors should create content and by which your editors review and approve it. Here are some examples of guidelines for a given element in a template:
- Character or word limits
- Image requirements (file type, size, etc.)
- Notes as to whether hyperlinks or multimedia can be embedded
- Type of text (paragraphs, phrases, bullets, etc.)
- Whether the element is mandatory
In fact, you might even want to explain why certain standards are in place. For instance, instead of simply stating that titles need to have 60 or fewer characters, you might explain that titles longer than 60 characters get truncated in search-engine results, leaving searchers to wonder what lies beyond the ellipsis and making your company look a bit less polished. Or you might describe a rationale for using short bullets in one section based on what you know about your audience’s preference for scanning snippets over reading a nuanced narrative. (These are just examples; your guidelines will vary.)
The Ultimate Blog Marketing Checklist: 65 Tips, Tools, and Resources
Step 5: Capture the guidelines in a fill-in-the-blanks template
Now, bring it all together in a straightforward, easy-to-use content template, table or spec sheet that your authors can follow to produce complete, consistent, high-quality content every time.
Let’s look at a content template that we created for a client in the corporate-social-responsibility space. This client wanted to begin a web-based customer spotlight series that would also be used for nurture campaigns. The content team knew that this type of piece would be written by a variety of people: their own marketers, agency writers, even an occasional salesperson. We came up with a customer spotlight template that looks like this:
Click to enlarge
Download a sample template here.
This content template includes elements that authors need to include in each customer spotlight (such as “content title”) as well as guidelines for each element (such as “Put the content title in title case” and “If possible, match the content title to the meta title”).
Step 6: Roll out the template, and keep refining it
Any tool is only as good as your team’s ability — and willingness — to use it. Train your people — your content creators and subject matter experts — on how they can use your templates to streamline and simplify the process of developing, reviewing, revising, and approving consistent, quality content. Make sure that the templates are easy to access.
And evolve your templates as you learn what works, what can be improved, and how your content can be structured to best meet the needs of your audiences and employees. Don’t expect to set and forget. Don’t live with an outdated template just because “the template is the template.” Your needs change. Templates should be living documents.
Should you apply new templates to your existing content? That’s up to you.
- You might want to update every historical asset of a certain type to conform to a new template.
- You might want to update popular assets only.
- You might want to use the new template for new content only.
For example, while it might make sense to refresh a dozen case studies to align with a new case-study template, you probably wouldn’t rewrite 50 landing pages from 2007 to align with a new landing-page template.
Content templates improve both your content process and your content itself. Luckily, getting started is simple. And you have good reasons to start today:
- Content templates make it easier for your content creators to do their job.
- Content templates reduce the time it takes for your reviewers to do their job.
- Content templates produce a more consistent experience for your audience, increasing the likelihood that they’ll engage with your content and, ultimately, take the actions you want them to take.
If you’re looking for a powerful tool that can help you clean up content messes — with or without the support of content management technology — give content templates a try.
Want more on managing your content strategically? Sign up for our Content Strategy for Marketers weekly email newsletter, which features exclusive insights from CMI Chief Content Adviser Robert Rose. If you’re like many other marketers we meet, you’ll come to look forward to his thoughts every Saturday.
Cover image by Joseph Kalinowski/Content Marketing Institute